Dad of a Mormon wrote:In the end, either Will used the C-word or he didn't. Obviously, someone is lying. If harmony, MrStak, and Spurven are all lying, I find it reprehensible. But the evidence is clearly on their side. I just think that one side should own up to what happened. And based on the evidence we have, I think it is pretty clear that Will is lying.
Dad of a Mormon, with all due respect, I have to disagree with you that these are the only options. Ever heard of false memory syndrome? The human memory is created and highly malleable, and none of us can remember every detail that happens to us in a given day. Where the brain can't remember, it often fills in the gaps with words, phrases, and other memories that seem to fit. People are also known to have involuntarily erased memories of things they have done that they are ashamed of and to have passionately defended false memories even after being shown that they aren't true.
I don't want to go into details, but I grew up in an abusive home situation. I could give a lot of very specific accounts of the things my father said and did to me and the abuse he heaped on me. If you asked him today (and he is a kinder, gentler man today), my father would almost certainly deny everything, and I don't think it's because he's a liar. I think that, in the eleven years since I left home, his brain really has involuntarily replaced the memories of what he did to me.
William's comment to
harmony was made over six months ago. He made it in the heat of the moment, it was probably one of dozens of comments that he was making around the Internet at the time, and he hasn't been reminded of it since. It's entirely possible that he no longer remembers making it and, thus, isn't lying. for what it's worth, I also don't believe that he was lying about not having remembered saying Emma Smith was a "champion bitch." I think he really did not remember saying it.
It is, however, entirely impossible that
harmony,
MrStakhanovite and
Spurven Ten Sing are jointly misremembering, and outright laughable to think that they've conspired to make something up about him.
As I said earlier in this thread, there was no conspiracy. This thread was my own doing, I alone took the initiative to get it done, and I think everyone would be surprised at the amount of time it actually took to compose. Coding the damned BBCode to look neat and clean was the most taxing part about it all. (I enjoy writing web code about as much as I enjoyed the hurtie needle part of getting my tattoo last year.)