Daniel Peterson wrote:
Some Schmo wrote:
It's just a commentary on how much church sucks. No child should be subjected to it. What a waste of a perfectly good day off from school. What... you missed that?
No, I didn't. That's why I pointed out that boys of certain ages also play hooky from school.
Which proves, I guess, that education sucks?
And they sometimes ditch chores.
Which demonstrates, I suppose, that children shouldn't be subjected to work around the house ?
And they often won't wear their retainers.
Which is just a commentary, it seems, on how much orthodontic dental care sucks?
And they sometimes won't take their medicines.
Which, I'm guessing, proves that medicine sucks?
And some don't like to shower or bathe or clean their rooms.
Which just illustrates, I suppose, how much cleanliness sucks?
We don't typically allow boys of a certain age to do only what they want to do, and to opt out of anything they don't want to do, assuming that their judgment is sound.
:rolleyes:
Hmmm... at what point did I say that his actions
prove anything?
But just for fun, let's assume I did say it (or at least, that it was what I meant).
Your analogies are spurious:
Daniel Peterson wrote:
That's why I pointed out that boys of certain ages also play hooky from school.
Which proves, I guess, that education sucks?
No, it proves that some kids think going to school sucks.
Daniel Peterson wrote:
And they sometimes ditch chores.
Which demonstrates, I suppose, that children shouldn't be subjected to work around the house?
No, it demonstrates that some kids think chores suck.
Daniel Peterson wrote:
And they often won't wear their retainers.
Which is just a commentary, it seems, on how much orthodontic dental care sucks?
No, it's commentary on how some kids think they're uncomfortable for whatever reason.
Daniel Peterson wrote:
And they sometimes won't take their medicines.
Which, I'm guessing, proves that medicine sucks?
No, it proves that some kids think taking medicine sucks.
Daniel Peterson wrote:
And some don't like to shower or bathe or clean their rooms.
Which just illustrates, I suppose, how much cleanliness sucks?
No, it illustrates that some kids would rather do other things than shower or bathe or clean their rooms.
But here's the real problem with your analogies:
Daniel Peterson wrote:
We don't typically allow boys of a certain age to do only what they want to do, and to opt out of anything they don't want to do, assuming that their judgment is sound.
Going to church is not in any way equivalent to the things you listed above, because it really is a useless activity, and is actually potentially dangerous. In this particular instance, the kid's judgment
was sound.
I didn't say that his actions prove that church sucks; church does that all on its own.