Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

The catch-all forum for general topics and debates. Minimal moderation. Rated PG to PG-13.
Post Reply
vessr
Star A
Posts: 99
Joined: Sat Jan 26, 2013 3:47 am

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by vessr »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Someone please read Chapter XX, verses 11-16 and tell me if I'm the only one seeing an amazing coincidence.


not enough to support a charge of plagiarism, in my opinion.

User avatar
Shulem
Son of Perdition
Posts: 10954
Joined: Thu Jun 30, 2011 7:48 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Shulem »

DrW wrote:Just over 1,100 views in just over three hours.

That sound you hear is breaking shelves.

The acrid odor is sweating apologists.


Shades needs to pin this thread right away. Everything has changed. This is perhaps the greatest discovery since the lost papyrus were rediscovered in the 1960's. This is a new dawn, folks. Mormonism is in serious, serious, trouble.

Isn't it wonderful? :biggrin:

Paul O

User avatar
Kishkumen
Seedy Academician
Posts: 20898
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2008 4:00 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Kishkumen »

I don't believe what we are looking at is plagiarism. It is generic imitation. Joseph Smith seems to have become aware, most likely through Hunt, of this quasi-biblical prose epic genre and run with it for his own prose epic on Hebrews in Ancient America. There are simply too many echoes of Hunt's work in Smith's for this to be mere coincidence.
“God came to me in a dream last night and showed me the future. He took me to heaven and I saw Donald Trump seated at the right hand of our Lord.” ~ Pat Robertson
“He says he has eyes to see things that are not . . . and that the angel of the Lord . . . has put him in possession of great wealth, gold, silver, precious stones.” ~ Jesse Smith

User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3905
Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 8:53 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »




Kish, if that's the Mopologists' official reponse to your post, then on behalf of Mormons I humbly submit that we are screwed in regard to the Book of Mormon being historical.

I've only skimmed this book, and so far I've found numerous terms that are completely "unique" to the Book of Mormon. Hard to explain, at the very least.

I hope Cassius goes into full overdrive and reviews these books ASAP.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014

mms
Regional Representative
Posts: 642
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 3:10 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by mms »

DrW wrote:

That sound you hear is breaking shelves.



At least the pathway will be clear--there no longer being a need to crawl around the Book of Mormon to leave the Church.

User avatar
Blixa
God
Posts: 8381
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 6:45 am

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Blixa »

Kishkumen wrote:I don't believe what we are looking at is plagiarism. It is generic imitation. Joseph Smith seems to have become aware, most likely through Hunt, of this quasi-biblical prose epic genre and run with it for his own prose epic on Hebrews in Ancient America. There are simply too many echoes of Hunt's work in Smith's for this to be mere coincidence.


Exactly. "Plagiarism" was never really the point, though many people have misguidedly thrown that phrase around.
From the Ernest L. Wilkinson Diaries: "ELW dreams he's spattered w/ grease. Hundreds steal his greasy pants."

User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3905
Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 8:53 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

Blixa wrote:
Kishkumen wrote:I don't believe what we are looking at is plagiarism. It is generic imitation. Joseph Smith seems to have become aware, most likely through Hunt, of this quasi-biblical prose epic genre and run with it for his own prose epic on Hebrews in Ancient America. There are simply too many echoes of Hunt's work in Smith's for this to be mere coincidence.


Exactly. "Plagiarism" was never really the point, though many people have misguidedly thrown that phrase around.


Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.
Last edited by Everybody Wang Chung on Sun Oct 20, 2013 4:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014

User avatar
Shulem
Son of Perdition
Posts: 10954
Joined: Thu Jun 30, 2011 7:48 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Shulem »

Kishkumen wrote:I don't believe what we are looking at is plagiarism. It is generic imitation. Joseph Smith seems to have become aware, most likely through Hunt, of this quasi-biblical prose epic genre and run with it for his own prose epic on Hebrews in Ancient America. There are simply too many echoes of Hunt's work in Smith's for this to be mere coincidence.


I tend to agree. However, these works need to be combed over to make sure there isn't a silver bullet within the silver bullet. All it could take is one word. Much like the blood on the clothes of whats-his-name in the Book of Mormon which gave himself away as the assassin.

Paul O

mms
Regional Representative
Posts: 642
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 3:10 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by mms »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling warrior", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.


Was "stripling" used directly next to "warrior"?

User avatar
Blixa
God
Posts: 8381
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 6:45 am

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Blixa »

Image

"Have a slice of Emma's layer cake, boys..."
From the Ernest L. Wilkinson Diaries: "ELW dreams he's spattered w/ grease. Hundreds steal his greasy pants."

User avatar
Everybody Wang Chung
God
Posts: 3905
Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 8:53 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Everybody Wang Chung »

mms wrote:
Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.


Was "stripling" used directly next to "warrior"?


Good catch. I need to slow down. Here's the quote I was referring to:

32. About this time, a stripling from the south, with his weapon of war in his hand.

Chapter XIX, verse 32
"I'm on paid sabbatical from BYU in exchange for my promise to use this time to finish two books."

Daniel C. Peterson, 2014

User avatar
Blixa
God
Posts: 8381
Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 6:45 am

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Blixa »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling warrior", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.


If it's just a word or short phrase, then barely bordering---and other than "stripling warrior," I imagine one could find the other phrases elsewhere, too. Nothing in the text ever sounded completely outside of 19thC vernacular, to my ears....
From the Ernest L. Wilkinson Diaries: "ELW dreams he's spattered w/ grease. Hundreds steal his greasy pants."

User avatar
Shulem
Son of Perdition
Posts: 10954
Joined: Thu Jun 30, 2011 7:48 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Shulem »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling warrior", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.


Each point adds up and the odds must be weighed. There is a cumulative effect that needs to be taken into consideration. It's clear to me where Joe Smith got his ideas and as Dr. Scratch pointed out, all Joe had to do was cut and paste. Presto!

Paul O

User avatar
DrW
God
Posts: 7222
Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2009 8:57 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by DrW »

vessr wrote:
Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Someone please read Chapter XX, verses 11-16 and tell me if I'm the only one seeing an amazing coincidence.


not enough to support a charge of plagiarism, in my opinion.


But, taken as a whole, one could certainly say that, with the Late War, there are now known contemporary sources for language, style and religious and political themes in the Book of Mormon to go along with known contemporary sources for character and place names, and the source of the Anthon Caracters (purported examples of Reformed Egyptian).

This, taken together with JSJr.'s track record regarding the Book of Abraham, the Kinderhook Plates and the Greek Psalter, all sort of leaves him batting pretty much zero.

As Paul said upthread (sort of): Weight of Evidence (Baby).
Last edited by DrW on Sun Oct 20, 2013 4:32 pm, edited 2 times in total.
David Hume: "---Mistakes in philosophy are merely ridiculous, those in religion are dangerous."

DrW: "Mistakes in science are learning opportunities and are eventually corrected."

mms
Regional Representative
Posts: 642
Joined: Wed Oct 10, 2007 3:10 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by mms »

Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Good catch. I need to slow down. Here's the quote I was referring to:

32. About this time, a stripling from the south, with his weapon of war in his hand.

Chapter XIX, verse 32


Pretty easy to come up with stripling warrior from that, and then mix it with the 2000 that went to battle. Wow. Seriously, this seems to be an amazing find.

User avatar
Kishkumen
Seedy Academician
Posts: 20898
Joined: Sat Dec 13, 2008 4:00 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Kishkumen »

This expression of outrage on behalf of virtue violated is pretty interesting:

38. Instead of protecting the tender women, the fairest work of God, the life of the world; behold! what hast thou done?

39. See! the shrieking matron cast herself into the waters that she may escape brutal violence: but all in vain; her garments are torn from her; she becomes prey to thy savage lust.

40. Not she alone, but her daughter, and her fair sisters, have fallen into thy unhallowed hands, and been defiled!

41. Oh, Britain! the voice of violated chastity riseth up against thee; the mark of the beast is indelibly printed in thy forehead:
“God came to me in a dream last night and showed me the future. He took me to heaven and I saw Donald Trump seated at the right hand of our Lord.” ~ Pat Robertson
“He says he has eyes to see things that are not . . . and that the angel of the Lord . . . has put him in possession of great wealth, gold, silver, precious stones.” ~ Jesse Smith

Nevo
God
Posts: 1496
Joined: Sat Feb 24, 2007 10:05 am

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Nevo »

You guys are hilarious. Where did all the critical thinkers on the board go?

User avatar
Craig Paxton
God
Posts: 2370
Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2012 2:28 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Craig Paxton »

Shulem wrote:
Everybody Wang Chung wrote:Although, I think one would be hard pressed to say that the terms, "freemen", "stripling warrior", "fine workmanship", "curious workmanship", etc. don't border on plagarism.


Each point adds up and the odds must be weighed. There is a cumulative effect that needs to be taken into consideration. It's clear to me where Joe Smith got his ideas and as Dr. Scratch pointed out, all Joe had to do was cut and paste. Presto!

Paul O


What am i missing...unless something more sufaces...I don't see any smoking gun... If the plagiarism from the bible, twisting Pauls words into those of Alma's and Mormon arn't a smoking gun. How can this be?
"...The official doctrine of the LDS Church is a Global Flood" - BCSpace

"...What many people call sin is not sin." - Joseph Smith

"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away" - Phillip K. Dick

“The meaning of life is that it ends" - Franz Kafka

Themis
God
Posts: 13142
Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2010 12:43 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Themis »

Nevo wrote:You guys are hilarious. Where did all the critical thinkers on the board go?


It's just further evidence that the Book of Mormon has a 19th century origin. It fairly clear looking at other sources like Voth that the Book of Mormon story has the same kind of sources. The obvious apologetic will be for loose translation with Joseph just putting it all in his own words. Too bad loose translation just doesn't really fit the facts. We also KNOW Joseph did not get the Book of Abraham right. Should I pull a Shulem on you?
42

User avatar
Bazooka
God
Posts: 10719
Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2013 10:36 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Bazooka »

I think there are probably two things to focus on when considering similarities with the Book of Mormon (Given that the timescale and availability aren't in dispute).

1. General themes of events or circumstance.
2. Specific phrases that were seemingly unique to the Book of Mormon.

This type of 'scientific' comparison would give some degree of measure of probability of Joseph using it as an inspiration.
I assume somebody with the appropriate credentials (literary analytical skills) will be taking this book and placing it under scrutiny?
That said, with the Book of Mormon, we are not dealing with a civilization with no written record. What we are dealing with is a written record with no civilization. (Runtu, Feb 2015)

User avatar
Nightlion
World's Top Zion Scientist
Posts: 9897
Joined: Wed May 06, 2009 2:11 pm

Re: Possible Modern Source for the Book of Mormon

Post by Nightlion »

Holy Viagara Falls. Has it been more than four hours yet. Kish you better go see a physician. :lol: :lol: :lol:

Anyone who ever created a thing or two knows you can't go from nothing to something. I say the Lord provided Joseph Smith examples of Ancient Writing styles in his day to simmer on the back burner a bit lest he stumble over much when confronted with the language God was soon to provide him written on the stone in the hat.

I think the symphony of The Book of Mormon far exceeds the weak tones of these tomes.
The Apocalrock Manifesto and Wonders of Eternity: New Mormon Theology
https://www.docdroid.net/KDt8RNP/the-apocalrock-manifesto.pdf
https://www.docdroid.net/IEJ3KJh/wonders-of-eternity-2009.pdf
My YouTube videos:HERE

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests